Payday Loan or Overdraft – Which One Should You Choose?

- by Becky Hall

Are you stuck for cash again and not sure what the cheapest option for borrowing is – loan or overdraft? Cashfloat explores your best option for borrowing money in an emergency…


payday loan or overdraft. which one? Cashfloat

There are many times in life when you may struggle for money. You’ve had to spend a lot of money in a few weeks, and your bank balance is seriously low. For most people, a convenient solution is to get an overdraft. You contact your bank and ask to get an overdraft so you have access to additional funds. If they approve this, then you’ll have to pay a daily fee until you’re out of the overdraft. On the other hand, payday loans provide a quick short term solution too. Overdraft vs Payday Loans – Which will it be?

Loans or Overdrafts – The Cheapest Solution

There are lots of people in the red that think that an overdraft is the best solution out there. However, some new research by Which? has proved otherwise. During their research which compared an unplanned overdraft vs payday loans, Which? found that it was cheaper to take out a payday loan rather than an unplanned overdraft. This news came as a surprise to many people all of the UK. For years, payday loans have been scrutinised and given a bad name. Everyone has been warned off them and told to go to their bank for help instead. But, this new research has shown that unplanned overdraft fees can be four times more expensive than payday loans!

This news was shocking because it’s known that payday lenders can charge very high-interest rates. Some charge as much as 1,509% APR, and yet, they’re now cheaper than overdrafts. How is this possible? How can a payday loan be cheaper than getting an overdraft? All it takes is a quick look at some of the fees banks are charging their customers.


overdraft or payday loans - Cashfloat unplanned overdrafs can be way more expensive than payday loans - Cashfloat

Overdraft Vs Payday Loans Fees

If you bank with NatWest and RBS, then you’re charged a fee of £6 per day, for going into overdraft. It’s important to note that this is for unplanned overdrafts, not ones that are already agreed upon beforehand. This fee is for people that go into an unplanned overdraft by more than £10. At TSB, HSBC and Lloyds, they can charge you up to £80 a month for being in your overdraft. Over at Halifax, there’s a £5 per day fee, with a max charge of £100.

All of these figures can seem a bit confusing, and it looks like a lot of money is being charged to customers. And, things are made even worse when you compare how much it costs to borrow £100. There are new FCA rules in place that put a cap on how much a payday lender can charge per day. The most they can now charge is 0.8% each day. This equates to £122.40 for borrowing £100 over 28 days.

Bank Overdraft Fees
natwest iconNatwest overdraft £6 per day
barclays iconBarclays overdraft £8 per day
halifax logoHalifax overdraft £5 per day
hsbc logoHSBC overdraft £5 per day
lloyds iconLloyds overdraft £5 per day
tsb iconTSB overdraft £5 per day

The Facts about Overdrafts

The following charges are for borrowing £100 for 28 days when you borrow from a bank via an overdraft. These figures are straight from the Which? research. Barclays are the cheapest out there, with £100 costing you £30 – which is still more expensive. Then, the rest of the banks are way out in front. Borrowing from Santander can cost you a touch under £70. TSB, HSBC and Lloyds will all charge you £80 for borrowing £100. Moving further up the scale, RBS charge a maximum of £90. Finally, you have Halifax, who charge £100 for unplanned overdraft fees.

Overdraft or Payday Loans – Which One?

So, you can see that overdrafts are far more costly than payday loans. If you bank with Halifax, then it can cost you nearly £80 more! It may seem like an easy and convenient way of getting money, but unplanned overdrafts are very expensive. What’s more, it’s very rare that you’re told of these charges when you open a bank account. If you agree to have an overdraft, then you will know all the fees. And, yes, a planned overdraft is far cheaper than both methods. But, a lot of regular current accounts don’t come with them. So, you only find out about these fees when you need an unplanned overdraft. People that need one are often in a financial emergency. They’re desperate for money, and end up getting charged ridiculous fees. It’s not fair, and something needs to be done about it.

payday loan refund - cashfloat

Payday loans have become more affordable thanks to the FCA ruling. It’s been in place since January 2015, and you can see that it works. By capping interest rates, payday loans and short term loans online are now a much more viable option for people in need of emergency cash. And, it looks like banks are going to face a similar cap as well.

Will Overdrafts Change?

The CMA proposes that banks should cap unarranged overdraft fees. It’s thought that doing this can save customers £1 billion over five years. This cap would be very beneficial for lots of customers out there. Just look at some of the figures that were pointed out earlier. You have HSBC that charge around £30 max, and then RBS and Halifax that charge £100 max. There’s such a huge difference in scale; it’s not fair for everyone. The CMA also thinks that banks should alert customers before they go into their overdraft. Customers should get automatically signed up for text alerts to tell them when their balance is low. This helps them realise things are getting dangerous, and they can put a cap on their spending. They will be releasing a full report on their new proposal in August. Hopefully, this should give us more information on figures for the proposed cap, etc.

At the moment, banks don’t alert customers and charge ridiculous fees. They punish loyal customers when there’s no need for it to happen. Banks made over a billion pounds in 2014 from unplanned overdraft fees; that’s astounding! Hopefully, more and more people are now aware that it’s a bad option for them. So, they can save money and get a payday loan instead. Until banks put a cap on their fees, there will be the payday loan vs overdraft decision for people considering emergency cash advances. It’s ironic how people look at payday lenders as the bad guys in the financial industry. Banks would often tell customers not to get a payday loan if they were in trouble. Now, the tables have turned, and banks are seen as the bad guys!

Apply now with Cashfloat Apply Now with Cashfloat
Share
About The Author
Becky Hall
Born a writer, Becky Hall figured she would use her talents productively. So, she became a content writer for Cashfloat, and she loves it. A Business and Accounting graduate, Becky scored high, graduating with a first, but also acquired a professional certificate in addition to her main studies. She always dreamed of becoming an accountant, something she still may achieve, but in the meantime, she is helping to break open a new industry of honest and ethical lending. Becky spends her spare time at the piano, with classical music her favourite choice, but will play jazz to keep her baby happy. Nowadays, though, she doesn’t always have much time; Cashfloat has a revolution to make.
Blog disclaimer

We do all we can to bring you interesting, practical and valuable information. However, please understand the following:

Information and data on this blog are for information purposes only. While we work hard to ensure it is accurate, we cannot accept responsibility for the accuracy, completeness, suitability or validity of any information provided on the blog. We will not be liable for any errors, omissions, losses, injuries or damages arising from its display or use. All information is provided with no warranties and confers no rights.

If you feel that any of the information published on our blog is not accurate, please notify us via email at compliance@cashfloat.co.uk

Cashfloat is rated 4.81 stars by Reviews.co.uk based on 563 merchant reviews

4.81 / 5 Rating
563 Reviews
I think your company is amazing you are so quick and efficient and you are the most helpful company I have ever used, you take in consideration the individual not just their credit score. If only there were more companies like in this world alot of people would be so much better off. Thank you again for your unbelievable help.
Mr Peter Y
Very easy to apply and helpful throughout the whole process, thank you.
Ms M
Take care of their loyal customers, by tailoring their need reduce Apr and friendly staff, good company hope they strive for a long time
Anonymous
Bottom content

CashFloat is a trading style of Western Circle Limited - Company Registration Number: 7581337. We are fully authorised and regulated by The Financial Conduct Authority. FCA full permission license: 714479. ICO Registration Number: Z3305234


* Cashfloat terms and conditions apply. Applicants must be 18 or over. All loans are subject to affordability, applicant verification and traditional credit checks via various national databases by Cashfloat responsible lending policy. Loan limit maximum of £500 for first-time customers (£1100 for existing). In most cases, loan decisions may take up to 30 minutes during office working hours. If your bank does not support Faster Payments, funds will be sent to your account the same day as approval so long as you’re approved by 16:30.


Representative example: Borrow £500 for 4 Months, 4 Monthly Repayments of £215.81. Total repayment £863.24. Interest Rate PA (fixed) 270.10%, Representative APR 997%

Warning: Late repayment can cause you serious money problems. For help, go to moneyadviceservice.org.uk

This site uses cookies. Find out more.