Payday Loans vs Arranged Overdrafts

- by Isla Williams

Unarranged overdrafts are expensive. But what about payday loans vs arranged overdrafts, could that be a cheaper option?!

Payday loans vs arranged overdrafts explored by Cahsfloat
In this article, we will look at:
  • What is an arranged overdraft?
  • What’s a payday loan?
  • What is an unauthorised overdraft?
  • Do payday loans and overdrafts affect your credit rating?
  • What are the costs of arranged overdrafts?
  • What are the costs of payday loans?
  • How do payday loans and arranged overdrafts compare?
  • Can using payday loans vs arranged overdrafts be better for you?

Last year, Which did some research that discovered that instant decision UK payday loans are sometimes more affordable than unarranged overdrafts. But, how do payday loans compare to arranged overdrafts? Cashfloat explores.

Payday loans had a bad press a few years ago and have now been subject to increased regulation and a capping of interest rates and charges. So how do they compare now with authorised overdrafts from your bank? Read on to learn which is best suited for your needs. We look at the differences between payday loans vs arranged overdrafts, and consider which may be more suitable for you in different circumstances.

The payday loan industry grew massively in the 1990s to become a big money spinner for operators such as Wonga and Quickquid.

Payday loans  vs arranged overdraft explored by Cashfloat

What is Overdraft?

Most banks that offer current accounts will consider offering arranged overdraft. Indeed some banks include a “free” overdraft facility on some accounts (also referred to as buffer zone). These accounts allow you to overdraw by a small amount, often up to £250, without incurring any interest, charges or penalties. However, if you are relying on this facility every month, you need to look at controlling your budget more carefully to avoid of slipping beyond the limit. An arranged overdraft is available to most customers of the major banks who have a current account with the bank. (Note: Basic bank accounts don’t allow overdraft facilities).

Applying for Overdrafts

Usually, to apply for an arranged overdraft (otherwise known as an authorised overdraft), you will need to apply in your local branch or online. Your bank will want to know why and how much you are looking for in an overdraft. The bank will also want to know how long you want to arrange your overdraft to last. As with any other form of loan, your bank will look at your ability to control your finances. Leading to eventual repayment of the overdraft within the agreed timescale. They’ll also look at your previous banking history and credit score.

payday loans vs arranged overdrafts - cashfloat

If you have regular income paid into your account and a good record of avoiding overdrawing without authorisation, your bank is likely to look favourably on your application. Remember, banks make money from lending money, so if they think you’re likely to repay the overdraft on time they will look favourably on your application. The bank will probably want to know why you need the overdraft. They are more likely to approve your application if it can justify a transient need – maybe some emergency spending. Another reason will be if you have a short-term restriction on your income (loss of overtime for a defined period). Instead of just to pay off other debts or you seem to constantly struggle to keep spending within your income level it.

Authorised overdrafts can be arranged for a period of time to suit your needs and usually are granted for periods ranging from one month up to a year.

What is Payday Loan?

A payday loan is a short-term loan usually for a maximum of one month (to get you through to your payday). Although there are some lenders who will grant loans up to six months. The attraction of payday loans includes the ease and speed of application – often applications via the website or mobile app. This ensures that your application will be made within just a few minutes. When successful, you will receive the money into your bank account almost straight away. The FCA (Financial Conduct Authority) tightened up lending criteria and maximum charges for UK payday loans in 2015. Since then applications are more rigorously vetted. Payday loan companies are now required by law to check more carefully to ensure you can afford to repay any loan you apply for.

Payday loans vs arranged overdrafts explored by Cashfloat

Payday Loan Regulation Clampdown

Some payday loans are typically granted without the thorough checks employed by banks and other lenders. However, payday lenders are now required by law to make rigorous enquiries to ensure you can afford to repay your loan. The bigger payday loan companies all seem to require you to be able to provide proof of income and outgoings. They require an arrangement to repay your loan + interest in full on the expected date before approving your loan. However, using the online app or website application procedure, it is usually accepted or rejected within minutes. One of the most appealing aspects of payday loans is as soon as your loan is approved the funds transfer into your bank account.

Big well-known payday loan companies like Wonga appear to charge maximum interest rates of 80p per day for each £100 borrowed as regulated by the FCA. However, there are other payday loans available from smaller operators, often credit unions and co-operatives. If you have determined that you can’t resort to a cheaper option of borrowing with an agreed overdraft, check online for the best payday loan deals online. The major comparison websites and money-saving expert will help you find the cheapest option to meet your needs.

Cashfloat is here to give you the ability to access a quick and reliable payday loan that you may need. You can access from anything between £200 to £1100 within minutes. Just click the link and apply here.

Free debt advice help from cashfloat

Comparisons – Payday Loans vs Arranged Overdrafts

Payday loans vs arranged overdrafts are easier to obtain if you have a poor credit record. However, unsecured small loans are considerably more expensive than an arranged overdraft. A payday loan decision is usually made within a matter of minutes, so if your need is immediate, this is an advantage. However, if you are plan in advance, and you have good standing with your bank with an acceptable credit score this is a much cheaper option.

Can using payday loans vs arranged overdrafts be better for you?

Almost always the answer to this question is a resounding no – unless you have no other options. The costs of payday loans vs arranged overdrafts are much higher. The repercussions in damaging your credit score even further may present you with greater difficulties in trying to borrow in the future. Resorting to using payday loans vs arranged overdrafts is often a strong signal that you aren’t in control of your personal finances. You need to take a seriuos look at your earnings and expenditure, and make plans to ensure you spend less than you earn. If you are routinely short of money before payday, you are in trouble. Look for ways to add savings to your piggy bank when doing your weekly shopping. Saving on daily spending on things like expensive coffee shop trips and takeaway meals can really make a difference.

Summary: Payday Loans vs Arranged Overdrafts

In conclusion, to use payday loans vs arranged overdrafts are really a last resort when your back is up against the financial wall. Try to avoid any form of expensive debt such as payday loans if you can –. The high charges of the payday loan are going to make you even poorer next month. Take time to plan your finances to avoid overspending. Make provision for emergencies by putting a small amount away each week into a rainy-day fund. You can also plan for unseen expenses by having the much cheaper option of an agreed overdraft or low APR credit card on standby instead. A note of caution: do not fall for the temptation to dip into an overdraft or credit card for routine spending!


Payday loans vs arranged overdrafts explored by Cashfloat
About The Author
Isla Williams
Caribbean born Isla Williams is excited to join the Western Circle Educational channel team. A born writer, Isla had her first article published at age 9 in a local magazine. Isla's joy emerges when pen strikes paper, and she can tap into her creative self. "I love to share knowledge/information and help others to be in the know while being as friendly as I can.” Isla is an accountant by profession but has taken a break to do what she enjoys most. Mother nature is her best friend, especially when the Sun is shining. A keen surfer in her youth, Isla looks forward to those rare trips home where she joins her family and hits the waves.
Blog disclaimer

We do all we can to bring you interesting, practical and valuable information. However, please understand the following:

Information and data on this blog are for information purposes only. While we work hard to ensure it is accurate, we cannot accept responsibility for the accuracy, completeness, suitability or validity of any information provided on the blog. We will not be liable for any errors, omissions, losses, injuries or damages arising from its display or use. All information is provided with no warranties and confers no rights.

If you feel that any of the information published on our blog is not accurate, please notify us via email at

Payday Loans vs Arranged Overdrafts

Cashfloat is rated 4.81 stars by based on 539 merchant reviews

4.81 / 5 Rating
539 Reviews
Very efficient service thank you
Thank you so much for accepting me. I needed the money for my holiday and cashflow has helped me.
Great Company
Bottom content is a trading style of Western Circle Limited - Company Registration Number: 7581337. We are fully authorised and regulated by The Financial Conduct Authority. FCA full permission license: 714479. ICO Registration Number: Z3305234

* Cashfloat terms and conditions apply. Applicants must be 18 or over. All loans are subject to affordability, applicant verification and traditional credit checks via various national databases by Cashfloat responsible lending policy. Loan limit maximum of £500 for first-time customers (£1100 for existing). In most cases, loan decisions may take up to 30 minutes during office working hours. If your bank does not support Faster Payments, funds will be sent to your account the same day as approval so long as you’re approved by 16:30.

Representative example: Borrow £500 for 4 Months, 4 Monthly Repayments of £215.81. Total repayment £863.24. Interest Rate PA (fixed) 270.10%, Representative APR 997%

Warning: Late repayment can cause you serious money problems. For help, go to

This site uses cookies. Find out more.